There’s an art to writing New Yorker cartoon captions. The magazine has had a contest weekly for decades and there’s a video series with everyone from Jon Hamm to Jim Gaffigan giving it their best shot. They are always funny.

Queer Eye cast members Karamo Brown, Antoni Porowski, and Bobby Berk tried their hands here.

You can try it yourself here with a recent NYer cartoon. (The real caption will be on our Facebook page…)

Watch.