I’m a full-time artist and writer and my work uses vintage paint by number paintings, of which I have some 3000. Over the last 25+ years I’ve accumulated a wealth of knowledge on the subject, and I have LOTS of research material as well, maybe more than anyone on the planet. And I owe much to Dan Robbins and the incredible vintage paint by numbers he created and supervised in the early 50s. I salute the man and his work!
In 2001, (at my suggestion, btw) the Smithsonian Museum of American Art mounted a year-long retrospective and borrowed 20 plus paintings from the collection of 200 paintings I originally inherited from the late SNL originator, Michael O’Donoghue.
Robbins writes in his book that he had the idea for paint by number kits in late ’49, early 1950. He may have had the idea then, but he wasn’t the first.
From Robbin’s own book,
“Max had his lawyers do a quick patent search to determine if the idea of painting by numbers was patentable or if it had already been filed for a patent or copyright. Sure enough, the search turned up multiple variations of “by-the-numbers” concepts… And yes there were several paint by numbers filings, dating back as far as 1923… I was crushed. Someone had already stolen my idea.“
Exhibited in the Smithsonian show and in the catalogue was a painting produced by Picture Craft, Columbia Jay, on canvas, which I own and illustrate in my book, Transform Your Life with Color By Number (Regan Arts, 2016) It is dated and copyrighted 1949.
From the Smithsonian catalogue (illustrated below),
“Picture Craft Company kit, c. 1949-1955. A manufacture of artist supplies dating to the Thirties, the picture Craft Company began producing paint by number kits in 1949 [promotional material suggests as early as ’43] The company’s early kits were devised by Royce Caron, a commercial artist… Caron reportedly developed his paint by number idea during WWII as a therapeutic pastime for servicemen confined to hospital…. Lacking the financing to market the idea, not until moving to Decatir, Ill, and later Sprigfield, Ill. Caron marketed his kits through Picture Craft…“
The Paint By Number Museum website also has images of Picture Craft paintings and kits dated as far back as 1948, (illustrated above.)
What an amazing long life and career and what a contribution to pop culture Robbins made. So, not “inventing” or “creating the very first” paint by number takes nothing away from his incredible accomplishments. But, the headline,
“Inventor of Paint By Number Dies”
has been repeated over and over and will continue to be for all of internet eternity. Somehow learning of my work and my association with PBN, both the BBC and NPR contacted me for a quote about Robbins and paint by number. When I spoke with BBC producer Sarah Birbaum and told her about my enthusiasm for the genre and sadness that Robbins had passed, I also shared the timeline of the creation of paint by number kits. She then said to me,
“Let’s hold off on the interview for now…“
This new info didn’t fit the narrative of the story they had in mind. She later wrote to say she spoke with ex-Smithsonian curator Larry Bird, and didn’t refer to Robbins as the “inventor” of the genre.
I returned NPR’s Elizabeth Blair‘s call, and I later heard back and she wanted some info from me via email, but it was too late. Like CNN, ABC News, NBC News, The Guardian, the Los Angeles Times, The New York Times and a host of others, the NPR story, contained similar info, but Blair stopped short of calling Robbins the creator of the first paint by number.
Robbins was a legend in the world of paint by number and will be remembered fondly as such. He created THE most collectible kits ever, Queen Elizabeth II and the Braque-inspired still-life, Abstract No. 1 that he showed to Max Klein to sell him on the idea ask well as scores of others. He was already assured a place in American history, creator or not.
Well, one thing I’ve learned through this and other stories I’ve been intimately involved with, history is often wrong. There are scores of pieces over the years saying Robbins created the first paint by number, as well as a Wikipedia page that people will no doubt use to research and repeat this as fact. Over all the years, not one interviewer did their research and asked him if there were manufactured kits prior to Craft House’s? Apparently not.
“I read it on the internet. It must be true. Let me repeat it.“
Andy Warhol is the most famous and popular pop artist in history, but he didn’t “invent” pop art and 100 headlines saying that he did, won’t make it so.
But if we’ve learned one thing from the age of Trump it is this –repeat a story again and again and again. It WILL become the truth, if there’s no one to refute it. And even then, the most press still wins.
Below is a segment CBS Sunday Morning‘s Bill Geist did on the Smithsonian exhibit in 2001 where you’ll see the show and Robbins himself talk about his involvement in the craze he helped create. There’s also a visit to my Brooklyn brownstone and a short tour of my collection at the time.
RIP, Mr. Robbins. You created SOME life and legacy, inventor or not.
(Photos, screen grabs, YouTube, the Smithsonian, Paint by Number Museum, personal archive)