Upon returning home from Princeton, older brother Lyle Menendez (played by Nico Tortorella) sits down with younger brother Erik (Myko Olivier) to play video games and catch up on family life. The conversation quickly turns dark, though, as Erik quietly admits that he’s still being molested by their father. Watch the gripping new clip below.

Menendez: Blood Brothers premieres next Sunday at 8/7c on LIFETIME.